Check into an upscale hotel today, and you may be handed a pillow menu: memory foam, buckwheat [the one I want to try], goose down, firm or plush. Our culture has turned comfort into an art. Against that background, the picture of Yaakov Avinu on his way from Be’er Sheva to Charan is jarring. Alone at nightfall, he gathers stones and lays his head on them.
If the stones were a headrest, as some interpret, why would Yaakov choose rock over anything softer? Lekach Tov explains that the stone pillow was a prophetic allusion: his descendants would one day receive the Torah, given on luchos even, tablets of stone. The Torah’s “ways are ways of pleasantness,” but it is also hard and unyielding. Even for the holiest among us, submitting one’s will to the will of Hashem demands real sacrifice.
That difficulty is no defect; it is where much of the meaning comes from. R. Joseph B. Soloveitchik put it starkly:
Religious activity is, in essence, an experience of suffering. When a person encounters God, a personal sacrifice is demanded of him by God… Offer your sacrifice! This is the essential command given to the homo religiosus.
His daughter, Dr. Tovah Lichtenstein, noted that his American-born students did not reject this message, even though it ran against everything around them. Despite their comfort and success in the goldene medineh, she suggests, the American Jew “needed to feel that he, too, was connected to Jewish history, with its fair share of pain, struggle and sacrifice.”
Still, the stone is not the whole story, and for many people it shouldn’t be the headline. This is especially true for children, who respond to warmth far more than to severity. Rabbi Moshe Feinstein observed that many first-generation American Jews saw observance as a burden. Their parents lost a job every Erev Shabbos and came home sighing, “Siz shver tzu zayn a Yid,” it’s hard to be a Jew. Rav Moshe acknowledged the challenge was real, but he insisted the message we pass on must be “Siz gut tzu zayn a Yid,” it’s good to be a Jew.
We need both the stone and the pillow, the shver and the sweet. Focus on the Torah’s sweetness, the darchei noam, but when Halacha does ask us to sacrifice, may we find in that sacrifice the depth it is meant to give us, and say wholeheartedly: Siz gut tzu zayn a Yid.